Are we free….Or should we depend on destiny??

A man came to Junnaid, a Sufi mystic, and asked him,
”What do you say about pre-determination, kismet, fate, and the freedom of man?
Is man free to do whatever he wants to do?
Or is he simply a puppet in the hands of an unknown puppeteer, who simply dances the dance that the puppeteer chooses?”
Junnaid is one of the few beautiful mystics.
He shouted at the man, ”Raise up one leg!”
The man was a very rich man; Junnaid knew it. All the disciples, the whole school knew about it – and he had shouted so loudly and so rudely,
“Raise one leg up!”
And the rich man had never followed anybody’s orders; he had not gone there to follow orders.

And he could not conceive even a far off, far-fetched, off-the-wall relationship between his question and this answer.

But when you are facing a man like Junnaid you have to follow him.
He raised his right leg.
Junnaid said, ”That is not enough. Now raise the other, too.”
Now the man was at a loss, and angry also.
He said, ”You are asking absurdities!
I had come to ask a philosophical question – that you simply dropped without answering.
You asked me to raise one leg, I raised my right leg. And now you are asking me to raise the other, too.
What do you want?
How can I raise both legs?”
Junnaid said,
“Then sit down. Have you received the answer to your question or not?”
The man said,
“The answer to my question has not been given yet. Instead you have been training me in this parade!”
Junnaid said,
“See the point: when I said, ‘Raise one of your legs’ you had the freedom to choose either the right or the left.
Nobody was determining it, it was your choice to raise the right leg.
But once you had chosen the right leg you could not choose the left too. It is your freedom that has determined the fact of your bondage. Now your left leg is in bondage.”
Man is half free and half in bondage, but he is free first.
And it is his freedom, how he uses his freedom, that determines his bondage.
There is nobody sitting there writing in your head or making lines on your palms.

You are free, but each act of freedom brings a responsibility – and that is your bondage. Either call it ‘bondage’, which is not a beautiful word, or call it ‘responsibility’.
*That is what I call it. You choose a certain act – that is your freedom – but then the consequences will be your responsibility.*


About Dr. Nikhil Aggarwal

I am a doctor by profession, resident of Gurgaon, Haryana. I want to enjoy every moment of my life and face the challenges as they come. In my view traveling is one of the best ways to detoxify our mind, body & soul. Wherever I go I try to explore the destination as much as possible. Recently, I have started writing and sharing my experiences & knowledge through my blog.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to Are we free….Or should we depend on destiny??

  1. Vijay says:

    Rousseau J. J. the great philosopher said ” Man is born free but always he is in chains”
    As a child he is born free, but as he grows the society puts on him the bondage or what is called responsibility.
    A very good lesson by Junnaid.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s